POLS208-1 Politics & Religion in the U.S.
Suffolk University
Fall 2026
Prof. Kelder
Sebastian Graff
How Roman Catholics Brought Morality to the Secular People
Although modern secular society is constructed upon the empirical foundations of modern science, history, and rational inquiry, its core ethical framework remains deeply indebted to religious and specifically Roman Catholic moral traditions that must be consciously translated into secular reason to sustain human flourishing.
The Divided House: A Short Tale
Growing up at our family’s kitchen table, I developed an early perception of the world based on two distinct philosophies separated solely by the fact that they came from opposite sides of that table, not by conflict, but by two very different understandings of how to interpret the world we live in. One side of this divide consisted of my mother and grandmother, who both came from Peru and were raised in the tradition of Roman Catholicism. When challenges occur in her life, my mother finds comfort in the quiet act of praying to La Virgen de Guadalupe. My grandmother has been a faithful member of her church for all of her life. The other side of the table was occupied by my grandfather, a university statistics professor with an academic background based on empirical evidence, history, and the study of Indigenous cultures. As such, there were never times when we could be said to have attended church together, nor did we recite traditional prayers or follow a set pattern of worship. And yet, living between the intuitive nature of devout Catholicism and the intellectual curiosity of secular historical inquiry made me aware of something significant regarding the modern world. Although today’s secular society is founded upon science and rational thought, it continues to draw many of its most profound moral convictions compassion, resilience, and duty from religion. While math was never my best subject, my grandfather’s love of the way historical events influence human identity gave me a grounding in scientific reality, while my mother and grandmother instilled in me the moral values that were passed along through their faith. In short, morality does not have to lose its religious roots to survive in a scientific era. Rather, what must happen in today’s secular society is that it needs to translate these learned virtues into common human reason.
Secular Humanism and the Physical Universe
My own personal views and way of viewing life can be defined by Secular Humanism, which is a belief system that pairs a scientific worldview with an atomistic understanding of the universe (Hasanoglu, PHIL 123-2). It is an attempt to bring about that same translation. The idea behind Secular Humanism is based on modern science as well as recognizing that humans are fundamentally made up of the basic building blocks of matter: atoms. There is no predetermination to serve any purpose in the universe’s grand plan. Death, as Epicurus wrote in his Letter to Menoeceus, is “nothing to us” (Epicurus, Letter to Menoeceus). It does not represent a passage from mortal to immortal, and therefore represents simply another type of sleep—an eternal sleep, void of dreams. While accepting this reality may present many challenges for a person attempting to live a “good” life, there is little alternative if one wishes to avoid both despair and nihilism. In addition, while Tom Holland writes in Dominion that Secular Humanism has inherited the ethics of Christianity, modern secular ethics such as human dignity and compassion have been secularized and should become the primary focus of our lives, given that they appear to be all we will ever have (Holland, Dominion).
Determinism, Stoic Agency, and Shifting Norms
The scientific viewpoint of life, however, creates a number of difficult problems for individuals who grapple with free will, social conditioning, and moral accountability. We are all the products of parents, families, cultures, and historical periods over which we had no control. Our ideas, actions, and behaviors have been formed by forces outside our own control. Stoicism resolves these conflicts regarding free will through compatibilism and the concept of the dichotomy of control. Chrysippus’s cylinder analogy illustrates how, even though external factors can influence us in many ways, it is ultimately up to each individual’s internal nature or their rational choice (prohairesis), as defined by Epictetus, to determine how we react. Although our circumstances at birth are clearly determined, acknowledging this allows us to make conscious decisions regarding our thought processes rather than simply drifting along with the tide of culture. Richard Hooker, a sixteenth-century theologian, wrote, “Wherefore the natural measure whereby to judge our doings, is the sentence of Reason, determining and setting down what is good to be done” (Kelder Supplement Two, 59). It is necessary to use reason when deciding what is right versus wrong, as social norms and acceptable behavior continually evolve. For example, some accepted practices currently being normalized (such as excessive alcohol consumption), although clearly harmful according to available medical data, may come to be seen as destructive within time frames similar to those used to recognize previously accepted practices that are now widely recognized as immoral.
The Ultimate Concern: The Sacred Rarity of Human Life
Beginning with my ultimate concern, what is central to how I view the world I see the existence of humans as a long-lived species as the most important value. My philosophy can be summed up very simply: being born human is statistically almost impossible. As Carl Sagan explained so eloquently in Cosmos, we are made of “star-stuff” (Sagan, 233). We exist as a unique means by which the universe has been able to reflect upon itself. Therefore, rather than belittling the fact that our existence is cosmically insignificant, we should consider it an absolute honor to experience life in all forms (both good and bad) and recognize this experience as both sacred and beautiful, as a delicate and fragile species that must save itself if it hopes to extend the human story.
Grounding Beliefs in Nature and Civic Action ‘
There is a great deal that I can do to maintain my sense of connection with these feelings. One thing I do is go hiking, listen to birds, and watch all the small parts of nature working together. This makes it easier for me to remember how large the natural world is and how beautiful it can be. At the same time, expressing my thankfulness for having a human experience has led me to give back to the community; one way I do this is by becoming politically active as part of Turning Point USA (TPUSA). Political activism provides an outlet for me to express my values and engage in open civil dialogue regarding the problems we face both locally and globally. Becoming involved in my country’s affairs and arguing the merits of various ideas are two of the ways I strive to honor the protection and advancement of humanity.
Balancing Self-Care and Outward Service
In reality, it is about finding an equilibrium between satisfying one’s own needs and fulfilling a purpose beyond oneself. Through writings on my blog, conversations with fellow individuals, and political activism, I intend to stimulate critical thinking in others. But because most people cannot create value to benefit the greater good until their own basic needs for safety, love, and happiness have been fulfilled, no one can be expected to provide meaningful contributions without first providing for themselves.
The Moderate Path in a Polarized Age
When I carry those values into the realm of politics, it puts me on the map as a moderate Republican who has conservative views; however, I have a tremendous appreciation for humanity’s complexities. I am very opinionated regarding many things, yet I truly believe there is much to learn from each side of the aisle. There are certainly some challenges navigating spaces such as TPUSA (where the overall movement often tends to fall toward one end of the extreme or the other), while my Secular Humanism, along with my historical perspective, pushes me toward the nuance, dialogue, and thoughtful debate that every single human being should practice in their own actions.
Translating Moral Intuitions into Public Reason
When values of a moral nature become part of public discussion, there are only two extreme options: either one religion dominates public life, or no religious thought can be considered in the process of deciding how we should act together. If we wish to find a way forward based on philosopher Jürgen Habermas’s theory of “translation”—translating moral impulses from religions into a common good accessible through secular public reason (Habermas, Between Naturalism and Religion)—we can see examples from American history. Historian David L. Holmes has noted, “If the nation owes much to the Judeo-Christian tradition, it is also indebted to Deism, a movement of reason and equality that influenced the Founding Fathers to embrace liberal political ideals remarkable for their time” (Kelder Supplement Two, 70). Thomas Paine similarly reduced morality to universal human duties, writing, “I believe in the equality of man; and I believe that religious duties consist in doing justice, loving mercy, and endeavoring to make our fellow-creatures happy” (Kelder Supplement Two, 71). On the other hand, when debating alcohol consumption publicly, I speak about the empirical evidence from health organizations rather than advocating that everyone follow my private morals. This creates a social ethical system anchored in human flourishing, preventing both religiously based authoritarianism and moral relativism. Even though I have no intention of joining and will never join a formal religious organization, Buddhism fascinates me intellectually. From the perspective of an American citizen who views practicing Buddhists as relatively uncommon, I appreciate Buddhism’s emphasis on mindfulness, the transience of existence, and the reduction of suffering, concepts that appear to align surprisingly well with both Epicurean detachment and Stoic self-control.
The “Loud but Little” Problem in Organized Religion
The current condition of organized religion in 2026, however, demonstrates to me that many large religious institutions create far more problems for both the masses and those who attend than they solve. This is the “loud but little” issue we have today, which stems from affective polarization and social media algorithms that amplify fringe minorities over moderate majorities. Modern society experiences this same distortion in the video game industry (where vocal toxic minorities dominate community conversations), in politics (where extreme partisans overwhelm practical problem solvers), and in the fitness industry (where sensationalized influencers overpower science-based and reason-based health information). Religious organizations suffer from the same pathology. Many loud conservative religious voices express rigid morality publicly while practicing hypocrisy privately, leaving the majority of the quiet, good-intentioned faithful feeling excluded from their community. Over two hundred years ago, Thomas Paine wrote: “My own mind is my own church. All national institutions of churches, whether Jewish, Christian or Turkish, appear to me no other than human inventions, set up to terrify and enslave mankind, and monopolize power and profit” (Kelder Supplement Two, 71). Even Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. lamented: “So often the contemporary church is a weak, ineffectual voice with an uncertain sound” (Kelder Supplement Four, 17). He urged us to turn our focus to “the inner spiritual church, the church within the church, as the true ekklesia and the hope of the world” (Kelder Supplement Four, 17). If humanity is going to survive in this digital era without fracturing into chaos, faith needs to transition away from massive, politically driven organizations toward individual conscience and small, genuine local faith communities.
Freedom of Conscience as the Foundation of Liberty
Ultimately, my ability to hold and express a philosophy that incorporates elements of Catholicism, embraces Secular Humanism, and critiques institutional religion depends upon the continued existence of religious freedom. A system of merely tolerating religions, such as that practiced by the first Puritans in Massachusetts (who sought religious freedom “for themselves and not for others”) (Kelder Supplement Two, 25), may allow me to live without persecution, though it could still lead to social marginalization for being unaffiliated. However, if there is neither freedom nor tolerance, expressing this philosophy will require me either to deny who I am or risk losing personal autonomy. As Thomas Paine wrote, “Infidelity does not consist in believing, or in disbelieving; it consists in professing to believe what he does not believe” (Kelder Supplement Two, 71). Therefore, liberty of conscience protected by principles similar to those contained within the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, which states “that no man shall be compelled to frequent or support any religious worship, place, or ministry whatsoever… nor shall otherwise suffer, on account of his religious opinions or belief” (Kelder Supplement Two, 22)—provides an individual with the necessary conditions to pursue knowledge about the world around them, inherit the best moral lessons of history, and develop a rational, stable, and compassionate future. That is the kind of society we should all want.
Works Cited
Epicurus. Letter to Menoeceus. Translated by Robert Drew Hicks, c. 300 BCE.
Habermas, Jürgen. Between Naturalism and Religion: Philosophical Essays. Translated by Ciaran Cronin, Polity Press, 2008.
Hasanoglu, Kaplan. Class discussions and lectures. PHIL 123-2: Social Ethics: The Good Life, Suffolk University, Fall 2026.
Holland, Tom. Dominion: How the Christian Revolution Remade the World. Basic Books, 2019.
Holmes, David L. “The Founding Fathers, Deism, and Christianity.” Encyclopædia Britannica, 2011. In POLS208 – Politics & Religion in the U.S.: Kelder Supplement Two, compiled by Graham Kelder, Suffolk University, Fall 2026, pp. 67–70.
Hooker, Richard. Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity. 1590s. In POLS208 – Politics & Religion in the U.S.: Kelder Supplement Two, compiled by Graham Kelder, Suffolk University, Fall 2026, pp. 58–60.
Kelder, Graham, compiler. POLS208 – Politics & Religion in the U.S.: Kelder Supplement Two. Suffolk University, Fall 2026.
Sagan, Carl. Cosmos. Random House, 1980
Leave a Reply